|
Joseph Alioto, former Mayor of San Francisco, died January 29, 1998
at age 81 after a long battle with prostate cancer. In the last months
of his life Mr. Alioto took an experimental drug.
A news story on the Internet last spring
shortly before Mr. Alioto died announced "Alioto recovering from
cancer." This story (on BayInsider.com) said Mr. Alioto had been
dying in early November but two months later had "regained enough
strength to read, chat with visitors and even consult on legal cases
by telephone."
BayInsider reported that Mr. Alioto credited
his recovery to "an experimental cancer therapy provided by an
Israeli physician, as well as the prayers of San Franciscans."
They said the doctor was Dr. David Rubin of Jerusalem. "The drug,"
Bay Insider reported, "a chemical compound called Glycosole, is
manufactured in Israel and has been used to treat a handful of terminally
ill patients who have not responded to conventional cancer treatments,
Rubin said."
Glycosole is manufactured by Dr. David
Rubin M.D. M. Sc., Medical Director of Co-Enzyme Technology, Ltd. of
San Diego, CA and Tel Aviv, Israel. In April 1998 we checked to see
if Dr. Rubin is Board Certified in California. He was not. We were unable
to find out if he has a license to practice medicine in the USA. He
is not listed as a member of the American Medical Association.
A Culver City oncologist, Dr. Stephen
Strum, reportedly cut off discussion with Dr. Rubin about his drug four
years ago when he found that Dr. Rubin persistently evaded reasonable
questions. A San Diego urologist, Dr. Israel Barken, who is fluent in
Hebrew, told us that he had tried to find out if Dr. Rubin has a medical
license in Israel and was unsuccessful in his inquiries. One person
Dr. Barken spoke to who had worked with Dr. Rubin urged caution, saying:
"He is fire."
Glycosole has not been tested or approved for
use by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. According to BayInsider,
"the FDA allow some patients with untreatable conditions to import
such drugs for personal use." In March 1996 the FDA said it was
"actively encouraging companies to submit expanded access protocols
in the United States for cancer therapies that have been approved by
recognized foreign regulatory authorities." Dr. Rubin apparently
has yet to take this route.
Dr. Rubin has been developing and patenting
versions of his drug since the late 1970's. He describes the latest
version of Glycosole as a non-toxic prodrug. He presents records of
tests on prostate cancer patients at two hospitals in Mexico.
Last spring, we became concerned that
men with advanced prostate cancer, including candidates for relatively
effective FDA-tested therapies covered by health insurance, were being
urged to contact Dr. Rubin to buy his drug. We contacted Quackwatch.
We also examined several of Dr. Rubin's patent claims. Soon after our
report, Dr. Rubin arranged to mail us a folder of material including
records of his prostate cancer clinical trials in Mexico. Is this a
magic bullet? We think it's a dud. You can read our translation of the
results of one these trials and draw your own conclusions.
In 1980 David
Rubin co-published an article in Medical Hypotheses.
Dr. Wallace Sampson looked at the abstract we sent him and connected
it with the theory behind laetrile.
Was this similarity accidental? We searched Rubin's patents
and found laetrile there at the start. Then we looked to see
of results were rosy in a clinical trial
of Glycosole for prostate cancer in Mexico.
|